Closed Mondays. Open at 11:30am Tuesday-Sunday, available by phone at 9:30am. Limited reservations for groups of 6-12 only, all other seating is first-come, first-served.

 

We are closed on Thanksgiving Day. Regular hours on Wednesday, November 25th and Friday, November 27th. 

Skip to content
Phone Icon

143 New Britain Avenue
Plainville, CT 06062

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday-Saturday

Sunday

Closed

11:30-10 pm

11:30-10 pm

11:30-10 pm

11:30-10:30 pm

11:30-9:30 pm

Catering Online Order

Let J. Timothy’s cook for you! We’ve taken our 46+ years of hospitality and entertaining experience at J. Timothy’s and created a catering/large take-out menu of high quality, plentiful food perfect for any occasion. Business Luncheon, Party, Family Dinner, Backyard Party – we’ve got you covered for any event!

Scroll down to order online. Please note we are closed on Mondays so cannot accept orders for Monday pick-up.

Click here to download/view/print the menu
Click here to see photos of our catering menu

Note:

  • Catering is pick-up only, we currently do not deliver
  • Orders must be placed a minimum of 72 hours in advance, except for wings only. Orders for wings only may be placed 48 hours in advance. Please note: we do get fully booked in advance. Even if you plan to place an order 72 hours in advance we might already be booked. The 72 hours and 48 hours ordering criteria is the minimum required.
  • Appetizers are based on 25 pieces or servings, i.e. if you order Jalapeno Poppers there will be exactly 25.
  • Half Tray items feed 8-12 people | Full Tray items feed 20-25
  • Disposable plates and utensils can be included for an extra charge based on the number of people.
  • Disposable chafing dishes with sterno are available for an additional $15.00 for each unit. You cannot order them on this form but if you’d like to include chafing dishes with your order place a note in the comments.
  • Prices do not include tax.

You can order online using the form below. You will not be asked for payment when submitting an online order. A J. Tim’s Manager will contact you soon after your order is submitted to confirm the order. NOTE: ALL CATERING ORDERS REQUIRE FULL PRE-PAYMENT. When we call you to confirm your order, we will get payment then.

If you’re not sure how much food to order, our experienced Managers will be happy to make recommendations. The quantity will depend on the time of day, type of function, and if you’re serving any other food.

Please note we are CLOSED on Mondays. Your order is NOT confirmed until a Manager contacts you. If your voice mail is full (which happens often), please call us. If you have any special requirements or questions, please note that in “Comments” section below.

We are CLOSED on Thanksgiving Day. If you‘d like Catering you can place an order for pick-up on Wednesday, November 25th to be re-heated at home.

For Christmas Eve, last pick-up for Catering is 2:30pm. We are closed on Christmas Day.

When selecting your pick-up date, if a day is gray (not black) on the calendar it means we are either already fully booked for catering that day or we are closed.

Each order is a 60 piece tray of wings. We have 5 flavors of wings. Each flavor except the Dry Rub can be done “Dirt Style” at no extra charge. Dirt wings are fried and sauced, then fried and sauced again for a slightly crispier, caramelized wing. Each order includes bleu cheese (8oz) and celery & carrots. If you do NOT want Dirt Style wings, please be sure to uncheck the box below. Note: we are unable to split flavors on trays of wings; one flavor per 60 piece tray. Thank you.
$90
$90
$90
$90

Our dry rub cannot be done Dirt Style.
$90
$4.00

Dressing will be on the side.

Mesclun greens, carrots, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, croutons, white zinfandel dressing.
$24.50
$42.00

Mixed greens, black beans, corn, tomatoes, cheddar & jack cheeses, fried tortilla strips, chipotle ranch dressing.
$33.00
$53.00

Chopped lettuces, cucumber, sunflower seeds, red onion, tomatoes, chick peas, fresh mozzarella, chopped basil, honey champagne vinaigrette dressing.
$33.00
$53.00

Mixed greens, cukes, tomatoes, red onion, julienne vegetables, shredded cheeses, choice of dressing.
$33.00
$53.00

Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons.
$33.00
$53.00

Add any of the proteins below to your salad. Generally, each order of a protein feeds 1-2 people.
$5.95
$8.95
$8.75
$16.25
$7.95

Pricing based on 25 pieces/servings.
$54
$54
$50
$45
$80

Pricing based on 25 pieces/servings.

With sauce on the side, dipped in sauce, or plain. If you'd like sauce, please note that in the comments.

With sauce on the side, dipped in sauce, or plain. If you'd like sauce, please note that in the comments.
$65
$51
$51
$51
$51
$54
$54
$45
$45
$45
$51
$54
$64
$51

All sandwich platters include our house-made potato chips. Condiments will be on the side.

Combo of wraps & rolls, sliced and trayed. Ham, turkey, and roast beef with lettuce, tomato, and Monterey Jack Cheese. Vegetarian option available upon request.
$75
$135

Combo of Genoa salami, ham and capicola with roasted peppers, provolone cheese, pepperoncini, lettuce, tomato, EVOO and red wine vinegar.
$80

Combo of tuna, chicken, and seafood salads, assortment of bread and rolls, lettuce and tomato.
$80
$35
$35
$35
$35
$55.00
$95.00
$55.00
$95.00
$55.00
$95.00
$55.00
$95.00
$55.00
$95.00
$55.00
$95.00
$45.00
$75.00
$45.00
$75.00
$35.00
$65.00
$35.00
$65.00
$50.00
$85.00
$60.00
$100.00
$50.00
$85.00

Bone-in, whole chicken cut-up, light & dark meat.
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$60.00
$100.00
$27.00
$47.00
$27.00
$47.00
$33.00
$58.00
$38.00
$68.00
$25.00
$43.00
$38.00
$68.00
$2.50
$2.50
$2.50
$2.50
$1.75

Complete the information below and a Manager will contact you to confirm your order. Please provide a phone number where you can be reached at any time. Please indicate if you want your food Cold for re-heating at a later time, or Hot to be served soon. Your order is not confirmed until you speak to a J. Timothy's Manager. Thank you!

J. Tim's Happenings

Exclusive Bourbon Celebration

THIS EVENT IS SOLD OUT! THANK YOU! Our staff once again traveled to Louisville, KY to hand-select an entire barrel of Old Forester bourbon. We’re having another awesome event to celebrate this exclusive bourbon. Info below: Date: Friday, November 13thTime: 6:00pmFood: A hearty buffet featuring Southern-inspired favorites from Lousville & Nashville. Scrolldown to see the … Continued

Fall Cocktails & Sangria To-Go

Fall Flavors Cocktail Dinner

Closed July 4th & July 6th-16th

Father’s Day 2026

Phone Icon

143 New Britain Avenue
Plainville, CT 06062

Phone Icon 860-747-6813

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, X, TikTok, and Untappd:

Facebook Instagram X TikTok Untappd

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

/Closed

/11:30-10 pm

/11:30-10 pm

/11:30-10 pm

/11:30-10:30 pm

/11:30-10:30 pm

/11:30-9:30 pm

Copyright J. Timothy's Taverne 2026 | Digital Marketing by Rebellion Group