• 860-747-6813
  • /
  • 143 New Britain Ave, Plainville, CT 06062
  • Temporary New Hours. RESERVATIONS STRONGLY RECOMMENDED: Mon, Tue & Wed: 3-8, Thu: 3-9, Fri & Sat: 11:30-9, Sun: 11:30-7 ... NEW, TEMPORARY LIMITED MENU. Click the banner below.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Untappd

Catering Order Online & Menu

PLEASE NOTE: We have reduced hours during the pandemic. Our hours are:

Monday, Tuesday & Wednesday: 3-8pm
Thursday: 3-9pm
Friday & Saturday: 11:30am-9pm
Sunday: 11:30am-7pm

Our phones are staffed 2 hours before the posted opening time above.

If you place a catering order online you will not be asked for payment; we will call you to confirm the order and the pick-up date and time. But Catering orders do require full pre-payment. When we call you to confirm your order, we will ask for payment then, you will not be asked for payment when submitting the order form below. 

.

Orders must be placed a minimum of 72 hours in advance, though some orders can be placed within 48 hours (mainly wings). Catering is pick-up only.

A manager will contact you after you place your order for confirmation and payment.

Prices do not include 7.35% sales tax.

Disposable plates and utensils can be included with all orders of over $100 based on number of guests.

Disposable chafing dishes with sterno are available for an additional $10.00 for each unit.

Appetizers are based on 25 pieces or servings.

Half Tray items feed 8-12 people | Full Tray items feed 20-25

If you're not sure how much food to order, our experienced Managers will be happy to make recommendations. The quantity will be depend on the time of day, type of function, and if you're serving any other food.

Your order is NOT confirmed until a Manager contacts you. If you have any special requirements or questions, please note that in "Comments" section below.

Gallery: Click here for a photos of some of the delicious items available from our catering menu.

Be sure to click "Add to Order" after you’ve made selections.

We have 4 flavors of wings (see descriptions below, click the little down arrow). Each flavor can be done “Dirt Style” at no extra charge. Dirt wings are fried and sauced, then fried and sauced again for a slightly crispier, caramelized wing. Each order includes bleu cheese (8oz) and celery & carrots.

If you do want Dirt Style wings, please be sure to check the box below.

Note: we are unable to split flavors on trays of wings; one flavor per 60 piece tray. Thank you.

Dirt StyleQty

Our Buffalo wings are considered “medium” spicy. Not too hot. We are about flavor, not necessarily heat.

60 piece tray $70

A delicious mix of honey and BBQ sauce, not at all spicy. Not too sweet.

60 piece tray $70

Asian-flavored with a slight kick of spice.

60 piece tray $70

A delectable combination of sweet and spice with a kick of heat at the end. We tested about 15 new flavors for about 8 months in 2014 asking our guests for feedback. This was the overwhelming favorite.

60 piece tray $70
$3.25

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

QTYQTY

Mesclun greens, carrots, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, croutons, choice of dressing. Dressings available: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Italian, Parmesan Peppercorn, Honey Champagne Vinaigrette, White Zinfandel Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard. Please include choice of dressing in the Comments of the order form.

Full $35.00
Half $17.50

Mixed greens, black beans, corn, tomatoes, cheddar, cheddar & jack cheeses, fried tortilla strips, chipotle ranch dressing.

Full $45.00
Half $25.00

Chopped lettuces, cucumber, sunflower seeds, red onion, tomatoes, chick peas, fresh mozzarella, chopped basil, champagne honey vinaigrette dressing.

Full $47.50
Half $25.00

Mixed greens, cukes, tomatoes, red onion, julienne vegetables, croutons, shredded cheeses. Choice of dressing. Dressings available: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Italian, Parmesan Peppercorn, Honey Champagne Vinaigrette, White Zinfandel Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard. Please include choice of dressing in the Comments of the order form.

Full $47.50
Half $25.00

Traditional Caesar Salad with romaine, croutons, grated parmesan. Anchovy paste is in the dressing.

Full $45.00
Half $22.50

Add any of the proteins below to your salad. Generally, each order of a protein feeds 1-2 people.

QTY
6oz $3.95
(6) $6.95
4oz $6.95
8oz $13.50
5oz $6.95

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

QTY
$46
$46
$42
$37
$68
QTY

With sauce on side or dipped.

$55
$42
$42
$42

Broccoli and Cheese

$42

With ham, onions, cheeses.

$45
$45
$45
$37
$37
$37
$68
$42
$45
$54
$37
$62
$42

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

All sandwich platters include our house-made potato chips. For more options, click Sides below.

QTY

Combination of wraps and rolls, sliced and trayed. Ham, turkey, and roast beef with lettuce & tomato. Vegetarian option upon request. Comes with Swiss, Cheddar, Pepper Jack cheeses and condiments.

8-12 ppl $65

Same as above, feeds 20-25 people.

20-25 ppl $125

A 3 foot grinder with a combination of Genoa Salami, Prosciutto and Capicola with roasted peppers, Provolone cheese, pepperoncini, lettuce & tomato, EVOO and red wine vinegar.

8-12 ppl $60

A combination of tuna, chicken, and seafood salad sandwiches, assortment of breads and wraps, with cheeses, lettuce and tomato.

8-12 ppl $70

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

QTY
feeds 8-12 $30
feeds 8-12 $30
feeds 8-12 $30
feeds 8-12 $30

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

QTYQTY
Full $85.00
Half $45.00

Thai peanut sauce; has a little spicy kick.

Full $85.00
Half $45.00
Full $85.00
Half $45.00
Full $85.00
Half $45.00
Full $85.00
Half $45.00
Full $85.00
Half $45.00

Tri-colored cheese tortellini with marinara sauce

Full $65.00
Half $35.00

Tri-colored cheese tortellini, Alfredo Sauce

Full $65.00
Half $35.00

Tri-colored cheese tortellini, Vodka Cream Sauce

Full $65.00
Half $35.00
Full $50.00
Half $25.00
Full $50.00
Half $25.00
Full $75.00
Half $40.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $75.00
Half $40.00

bone-in, whole chicken cut up, light & dark meat

Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $90.00
Half $50.00

Our baked scrod with cheese sauce

Full $90.00
Half $50.00
Full $95.00
Half $55.00
Full $40.00
Half $20.00
Full $40.00
Half $20.00
Full $50.00
Half $25.00
Full $60.00
Half $30.00

A blend of white and wild rice.

Full $36.00
Half $18.00
Full $60.00
Half $30.00

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

QTY
20 oz $1.75
20 oz $1.75
16.9 oz $1.25

Be sure to click “Add to Order” after you’ve made selections.
Added to Order

Complete the information below and a Manager will contact you to confirm your order. Please provide a phone number where you can be reached at any time. Please indicate if you want your food Cold for re-heating at a later time, or Hot to be served soon.


Pick Up Options*

Cold
Hot

Include Disposable Plates/Silverware (may be an extra charge)*

Yes
No

Catering Order Review

This order is NOT confirmed until a J. Timothy's Manager contacts you for confirmation. Someone will be calling or emailing you shortly to review the order. Thank you!

Your Information

Customer Name {{first_name}} {{last_name}}
Phone Number {{phone_number}}
Email Number {{email}}
Pick Up Date {{pick_up_date}}
Pick Up Time {{pick_up_time}}
Pick Up Options {{pick_up_option}}
Include Disposable Plates/Silverware (may be an extra charge) {{extras}}
Comments {{comments}}

Your Order

Item Size QTY Price Tax Ext. Cost
{{item.label}} {{ item.extra.dirt_style ? '(Dirt Style)' : '' }} {{item.size}} {{item.qty}} ${{item.price}} ${{item.tax.toFixed(2)}} ${{item.ext_cost}}
Order Total ${{grand_total.toFixed(2)}}